Category: Family Trees

Avoiding Genealogy Mistakes: Trust the Records, Not Trees

If you’ve been researching your family history for more than five minutes, chances are you’ve seen it happen.

One person adds a name to their online family tree. Another copies it. Then another. Before long, twenty trees claim your third-great-grandfather was born in “North Carolina, Ireland” and fought in three wars before age twelve.

Welcome to genealogy.

One of the biggest mistakes beginner researchers make is assuming that if multiple online trees say something, it must be true. Unfortunately, family trees can spread mistakes faster than gossip in a lunchroom.

And once incorrect information gets attached to your tree, it can lead your research completely off track.

Why Online Family Trees Are Helpful… But Dangerous

Online family trees can absolutely be useful tools.

They can:

  • provide clues
  • suggest possible family connections
  • help identify records to investigate
  • point toward locations and migration patterns

But here’s the important part:

A family tree is only as reliable as the research behind it.

Many online trees are built quickly, copied from other users, or created years ago before additional records became available. Some include excellent documentation. Others include… well… optimism.

I once saw a tree attach the wrong parents to an ancestor simply because the names “looked about right.” Genealogy is not horseshoes. Close does not count.

The “Copy and Paste” Problem

It’s tempting.

You find an ancestor with matching dates, matching children, and a dozen other trees connected to them. Clicking “Save” feels easy and productive.

But if no one checked the records carefully, you may inherit years of mistakes with a single click.

Common problems include:

  • combining two people with the same name
  • attaching children to the wrong parents
  • incorrect birthplaces
  • wrong spouses
  • incorrect military service
  • family legends treated as facts
  • unsourced information copied repeatedly

One small mistake can create an entirely incorrect branch of your family tree.

And unfortunately, the more a mistake spreads online, the more “real” it starts to look.

Records Matter More Than Trees

Experienced genealogists use family trees as clues, not proof.

The real evidence comes from records like:

  • census records
  • wills and probate files
  • land deeds
  • tax lists
  • church records
  • marriage licenses
  • military records
  • newspapers
  • cemetery records

A well-documented record is far more valuable than fifty unsourced online trees.

Think of family trees like breadcrumbs leading you toward records. The records are what actually help prove relationships.

Names Alone Are Not Enough

This surprises many beginners.

Just because someone has the right name in the right place does not automatically mean they are your ancestor.

In some areas, entire communities reused the same names for generations. In Scots-Irish research, especially, you may find:

  • multiple John Logans
  • multiple William Browns
  • three cousins named James living within five miles of each other
  • entire census pages that look like a copy machine malfunctioned

This is why experienced researchers study:

  • neighbors
  • migration patterns
  • land ownership
  • occupations
  • witnesses on documents
  • family associates

Sometimes, the people around your ancestor help identify the correct person more than the name itself.

Be Careful with Hints

Those little green leaves can be both exciting and dangerous.

Hints are suggestions generated by computer systems. They are not confirmations.

Some hints are excellent.
Some are wildly incorrect.
Some appear to have been generated during a caffeine shortage at 2 AM.

Always ask:

  • Does this record fit the timeline?
  • Does the location make sense?
  • Are the ages reasonable?
  • Do other records support this?
  • Is there actual evidence connecting this person to my family?

If the answer is “maybe,” keep researching before attaching it permanently.

It’s Okay to Leave Questions Unanswered

One of the hardest lessons in genealogy is learning to be comfortable with uncertainty.

Sometimes, the evidence is incomplete.
Sometimes, records were destroyed.
Sometimes, two people truly cannot be separated with the available information.

And that’s okay.

Good genealogy is not about building the biggest tree possible. It’s about building the most accurate one possible.

Slow Research Often Leads to the Best Discoveries

Some of the best genealogy breakthroughs happen after months of careful research.

A forgotten deed.
A witness on a marriage record.
A tax list.
A probate file.
A church entry hidden in old handwriting.

These discoveries usually do not come from copying someone else’s tree. They come from patient, careful work.

Genealogy is part history, part detective work, and occasionally part stubbornness.

Probably a lot of stubbornness.

Final Thoughts

Online family trees can be wonderful starting points, but they should never replace real research.

Do not add someone else’s family tree to your tree until you:

  • look for records
  • compare timelines
  • study locations
  • evaluate evidence carefully

Your family history deserves more than guesswork copied from strangers on the internet.

And trust me, future generations will appreciate not discovering their ancestor somehow fought in the Civil War at age six.

Need more help? Visit Loganalogy.com Research Specialist page. I offer guidance to streamline your research, provide expert tips, and help you build a family tree that future generations will cherish.

Explore Affordable Genealogy: Best Free Tools Available

Close-up of a computer monitor displaying a design layout with multiple images and text sections.
Photo by Tranmautritam on Pexels.com

Let’s just say it out loud.

Genealogy can get expensive fast.

Subscriptions, record fees, DNA tests… it adds up before you know it.

But here’s the good news.

Some of the best genealogy tools out there are completely free. And if you’re not using them, you’re probably missing valuable records.

1. FamilySearch

This one should be at the top of everyone’s list.

FamilySearch offers access to millions of records from around the world, including census records, probate files, land records, and more.

Their “Full Text” search feature alone can uncover documents you might never find otherwise.

2. Find a Grave

Gravestones can tell you more than you’d expect.

Dates, family connections, military service, and sometimes even full obituaries are linked here.

Just remember, it’s a helpful tool, but always double-check details against other records.

3. National Archives

If your ancestors were in the United States, this is a must.

Military records, immigration documents, and federal records can all be found here.

Some collections are digitized, while others may guide you on where to look next.

4. Chronicling America

Newspapers are one of the most overlooked genealogy sources.

Obituaries, marriage announcements, and even local gossip columns can give you insight into your ancestor’s daily life.

5. Internet Archive

Local histories, county books, and rare publications live here.

If you’re researching early American families or small communities, this site can be incredibly helpful.

6. USGenWeb

This one feels a bit old-school, but don’t let that fool you.

Volunteers have compiled records, transcriptions, and local knowledge that you won’t always find anywhere else.

7. WikiTree

A collaborative family tree where researchers work together.

It’s especially useful for connecting with others researching the same lines and seeing how your family might fit into a bigger picture.

Why These Matter

You don’t need every paid subscription to make real progress.

These free tools can:

  • Help you find records
  • Point you toward new sources
  • Confirm or challenge what you already know

And sometimes, the breakthrough you’ve been waiting for is sitting in a free database you just haven’t checked yet.

Final Thoughts

Good genealogy isn’t about how much you spend.

It’s about how you search.

Start with these free resources, use them well, and you’ll build a stronger, more accurate family tree without feeling like you need to buy every tool out there.

Need more help? Visit Loganalogy.com Research Specialist page! I offer guidance to streamline your research, provide expert tips, and help you build a family tree that future generations will cherish.

No-Fluff Family History Tips Straight to Your Inbox

If you have a “someday” family history project sitting in your brain, you are exactly who the Loganalogy newsletter is for.

Over the past few months, I’ve been sending out short, beginner-friendly emails packed with simple tips, honest encouragement, and practical tools to help you make real progress on your family tree. Think of it as family history help in plain English, from a researcher who has made all the mistakes so you do not have to.

And if you have not hopped on the list yet, now is the perfect time.

What the newsletter has been doing for readers

From the very beginning, the goal has been “No Fluff, Just Family History Help.” That is not just a cute slogan on the signup page. It is how I plan every issue.

So far, newsletters have focused on things real people actually struggle with, like:

  • Getting started without feeling lost. We talk about how to take that big messy pile of names, screenshots, and half-finished trees and turn it into a simple, step-by-step plan.
  • Avoiding common beginner mistakes. If you grabbed the freebie “12 Mistakes New Family Researchers Make,” you know I am serious about helping you dodge the time-wasting, head-smacking stuff early on.
  • Keeping family stories from disappearing. One of the first topics I wrote about was how easily family stories vanish by the second generation, and what you can do right now to save them with simple tools like voice memos, journals, and family interviews.
  • Using tools and cheat sheets instead of guesswork. I love sharing quick reference guides, worksheets, and checklists, so you can spend less time wondering what to do next and more time actually doing the research.
  • Building confidence, not just trees. Every issue is written to remind you that you can do this, even if you are brand-new to genealogy.

You do not have to be an expert. You do not have to know what a “FAN club” or a “soundex code” is. You just need a little curiosity and a willingness to learn one small thing at a time.

What you get when you subscribe

When you sign up for the Loganalogy newsletter, you get two big things right away:

  1. A free Genealogy Quick Reference Guide
    This is a handy cheat sheet to keep nearby while you research. It is designed to help you quickly remember key details and stay on track without flipping back and forth between a dozen tabs.
  2. Ongoing help directly in your inbox
    The newsletter is:
    • Short and easy to read
    • Beginner-friendly
    • Focused on practical tips, free resources, and tools to make family history feel less overwhelming

You will also hear about new blog posts, fresh free resources, and helpful goodies in my shop, so you always know what is available to support your research.

How often does it show up?

I respect your inbox. This is not a daily sales pitch or a never-ending stream of noise.

You can expect issues a couple of times a month, with occasional special notes if something especially helpful or time-sensitive comes along.

The goal is simple: every email should either teach you something, save you time, or give you a tool you can use right away.

Who this newsletter is for

You will feel right at home on this list if:

  • You are just starting your family tree and do not know where to begin
  • You have been poking around Ancestry or FamilySearch, but it all feels scattered
  • You keep thinking, “I really should write down Grandma’s stories before it is too late.”
  • You like the idea of getting guidance from someone who explains things like a friendly teacher, not a textbook

If you are further along in your research, you are still welcome. Many subscribers with experience tell me they enjoy the reminders, tools, and encouragement to stay organized and keep sharing their stories.

Ready to join us?

If you have been meaning to “get serious” about your family history, this is your nudge.

👉 Sign up here: https://loganalogy.com/loganalogy-newsletter/

You will instantly get access to the free Genealogy Quick Reference Guide, plus you will start receiving those no-fluff, high-help emails that keep you moving forward on your family tree.

Your ancestors lived full and fascinating lives. Let us make sure their stories do not disappear into a box in the closet or a hard drive no one opens.

Need more one-on-one support with a tricky branch or a brick wall?
Need more help? Visit Loganalogy.com Research Specialist page! I offer guidance to streamline your research, provide expert tips, and help you build a family tree that future generations will cherish.

Tracing Prussian Ancestry: The Story of Augusta

When we trace our family history, sometimes we stumble on a name that looks plain on paper but represents an entire life full of struggle, love, and resilience. For me, one of those names is Augusta Reikowska, the mother of Clara Elizabeth Schwitkowski/Hennig.

A Name, A Journey

Augusta was born in Prussia in the mid-1800s, a time when political upheaval and economic challenges pushed many families to seek a new start. Immigration records hint at her journey across the ocean, though the details of her passage are still foggy. What we do know is that she settled into a new country, carrying with her the traditions, strength, and determination of her homeland.

S.S. Switzerland

Life as a Mother and Immigrant

Like so many women of her time, Augusta’s story is often hidden in the shadows of census records and marriage certificates. Yet, her legacy shines through her children — especially her daughter Clara, who went on to raise her own family in America. Behind every census tick mark is the reality of daily survival: learning a new language, making a home in a foreign land, and holding a family together through uncertain times.

Digging into Prussian Roots

If you have Prussian ancestors like Augusta, you know how tricky records can be. Borders shifted constantly, and “Prussia” covered areas that today belong to Germany, Poland, Lithuania, and beyond. That means Augusta’s hometown might not appear under the same name today.

 Marriage of John Schwittkowski and Augusta Reikowski

A few tips if you’re researching Prussian records:

  • Check the church books: Lutheran and Catholic parish registers are often the best source for births, marriages, and deaths. Many have been digitized by FamilySearch or regional archives.

  • Look at gazetteers and maps: Historical maps can help you pinpoint a village’s modern location. The Meyers Gazetteer is a great free tool.

  • Explore immigration records: Passenger lists, naturalization papers, and local newspapers sometimes provide the only clues to an ancestor’s origins.

Even if you don’t find a detailed record for someone like Augusta right away, piecing together these breadcrumbs can reveal the bigger picture of your ancestor’s journey.

Hennig Family circa 1918

Why Augusta Matters

It can be tempting to skip past names like Augusta’s when we’re building a family tree, but pausing to dig deeper reminds us that every ancestor has a story worth telling. Augusta’s life reflects the broader immigrant experience of the 19th century — the courage to leave home, the resilience to start over, and the determination to create a better future for her children.

A Story Waiting in Your Tree

Augusta’s story made me think about the other “quiet” women in family history — the ones who don’t always have headlines or detailed obituaries, but whose lives were no less extraordinary. If you’ve ever looked at a name in your tree and thought, There’s not much to find here, I challenge you to pause. Ask yourself: what might their life have been like in their time and place? What history were they living through?

Sometimes the most meaningful stories are the ones waiting in the margins.

1529 S. 26th St

Augusta lived in the house above from 1910 until her death in 1964 at the age of 94. Her service was held at St. Lawrence Church.

St. Lawrence Church, Milwaukee, Wisconsin

She is buried with her husband at Mount Olivet Cemetery; Location: Block: 9 Section: 2 Row: Lot: 8-s Grave:

Obit

You’ll notice in this obituary that it says “née Reik,” meaning her maiden name. Yes, the Reikowskis changed their surname as well.

 

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Smart Content Strategies: Ditch What Doesn’t Work

How I’m Using Pinterest, ChatGPT, and a Bit of Common Sense to Work Smarter (Not Harder)

Lately, I’ve been rethinking how I manage my time, especially when it comes to juggling genealogy research, client work, blog updates, and social media. I’ll be honest: some platforms just aren’t worth the energy anymore. Twitter (or X or whatever it’s calling itself this week)? Noise. Spam. Trolls. Nope. And LinkedIn? A good idea in theory, but it just doesn’t work for my audience.

I gave both another shot recently, but the interactions felt hollow, the effort didn’t match the return, and honestly, I’d rather spend that time untangling a 19th-century census record.

Medium and Fiverr? Same deal. I learned that if I don’t own my content (like on Medium), I’m at the mercy of the platform—and I’m not about to lose hours of writing to a deleted post. Fiverr, while useful for some, didn’t generate leads for my genealogy services. So I walked away from both and haven’t looked back.

Enter: Pinterest, ChatGPT, Claude, and Content Strategy Magic 🪄

One thing I have added back into the mix is Pinterest—and this time, I’m actually seeing results. Thanks to analytics (and some trial-and-error), I’ve noticed Pinterest drives steady traffic to my blog and Etsy shop. It’s not just a place for recipes and DIY crafts anymore. It has become a visual search engine, especially for Gen Z, who now prefer it over Google for daily decisions.

Even better? Pinterest content sticks around way longer than a Facebook post or Instagram story. That’s what we call “evergreen,” baby.

I’ve also been using AI tools like ChatGPT and Claude, plus content strategist-approved tips to help me plan smarter, not harder. Tools like Canva have made it easier to create posts that look good and connect with the right audience without sucking up all my time. I now batch content, reuse templates, and prioritize engagement over perfection.

To make the most of what I create, I’ve started reposting my Instagram Reels to YouTube Shorts—same video, more reach. I’m also on BlueSky, but I use it mostly to network with fellow family historians rather than as a primary platform.

These updates have freed up my time and helped me stay sane.

What’s Working (and What’s Out)

Here’s my current social media + content strategy lineup:

✅ Instagram – Best for connecting with the genealogy community, sharing Reels, and building relationships
✅ Pinterest – Great for evergreen content, traffic, and reaching new audiences (especially younger ones)
✅ Facebook – Still solid for group engagement and community support
✅ YouTube Shorts – I’ve started reposting my Instagram Reels here for more reach without extra effort
☑️ BlueSky – I’m not actively posting, but I do use it to network with other family historians
❌ Twitter/X – Too noisy, too spammy, and too short-lived
❌ LinkedIn – Not the right vibe or audience
❌ Medium + Fiverr – Didn’t bring leads or lasting value

The Bottom Line

Sometimes the best way to grow is to stop doing what isn’t working. Once I let go of platforms that weren’t giving me value, I had the time and energy to focus on what does, and it shows in the quality of my audience connections and my productivity.

I’m keeping things simple, meaningful, and strategic. If it’s not moving the needle for Loganalogy, it’s off the to-do list.

Thanks for being part of this journey—I’ve got more tips, tools, and content updates coming your way. Let’s keep learning, sharing, and building those trees 🌳 together.

👇 Need help managing your genealogy journey or building a tree that actually makes sense?

Visit Loganalogy.etsy.com to explore tools, guides, and research support!

The Legacy of a Scotch-Irish Pioneer

John Logan was born in 1699 in Ahoghill, Antrim, Ireland1. (It is referenced that his father was from Restalrig, a suburb of Edinburgh, Scotland.) Restalrig is notable because my mother shared that my father named his ranch in Washington State “Restalrig.”

John Logan arrived in Boston, Massachusetts in 1717 and married Margaret Carr in 1723. Margaret, born in Massachusetts about 1703, remains a subject of ongoing research. The gap between John’s arrival and their marriage—six years—is a mystery still waiting to be unraveled. Together, they had eight children: seven sons and two daughters.

Service During the American Revolution

Two of their sons, John and Mathew, served under General George Washington during the battle for New York City in the American War for Independence. After the Continental Army became surrounded, Washington orchestrated a strategic nighttime evacuation to Philadelphia. John and Mathew likely endured the hardships of Valley Forge later on.2

Roots in Voluntown, Connecticut

John Logan founded the Logan family in Washington, Connecticut, and was descended from a lineage of Scotch barons. Their ancestral home, Logan, in Ayrshire, lent its name to the family. John immigrated with a group of Scotch Presbyterians led by Reverend Samuel Dorrance, a University of Glasgow graduate. After facing numerous challenges, the group traveled from Marblehead Harbor and Boston to Connecticut. There, they purchased Volunteer Grants in Voluntown and established the Presbyterian church on Ekonk Hill.3

The Scotch-Irish Influence in Connecticut

“John Logan, the founder of the Washington family, was descended from a long line of Scotch barons deriving their name, Celtic in origin, from the ancestral home, Logan, in Ayrshire. He came from the north of Ireland with the Gordons, Kassons, Keigwins, Parkes, Wylies, and other Scotch Presbyterians, under the leadership of Reverend Samuel Dorrance, a graduate of the University of Glasgow.

Their party, after experiencing a great many unusual difficulties, came from Marblehead Harbor and Boston to Connecticut, and buying up the Volunteer grants at Voluntown, forming the nucleus of the Presbyterian church Ekonk hill.”3

The Rising Sun Inn and the Logan Legacy

In 1748, John Logan built the Rising Sun Inn at 6 Romford Road in Washington, Connecticut. Originally a 1-1/2-story, five-bay lean-to house, it underwent significant renovations in the early 19th century. Matthew Logan, John’s son, expanded the house, adding three bays to the north, raising the roof to two stories, and incorporating a ballroom. The surrounding property features a historic barn, and photographs from the Sunny Ridge Historic District highlight additional barns that once stood behind the house.

A black-and-white postcard from July 1913 depicts the Logan Homestead—formerly the Rising Sun Inn—with its clapboard façade, dark trim, and multi-paned windows. The Gunn Historical Museum archives this image, offering a glimpse into the home’s storied past.5

Interesting Note: The Rising Sun symbol was associated with Edward III and appears in the arms of Ireland. It also served as a favorable omen for businesses and inns during that era.6

The Church on the Green
The Church on the Green: The First Two Centuries of the First Congregational Church
at Washington, Connecticut

We are related to the Hollister family. A Hollister Logan lived at the Logan homestead. I have a letter from her (actually, a friend wrote it for her as she was in her 90s.)

dvm_LocHist004193-00060-0.jpg
The Church on the Green: The First Two Centuries of the First Congregational Church
at Washington, Connecticut

Family Connections and Tragedy

John married Dorcas Root around 1771 after the death of his first wife, Margaret. Dorcas was previously married to John Royce; he died in 1760. Their daughter, Azubah, married John Logan, Jr. This makes John and Dorcas my double-sixth great-grandparents.

Dorcas died on 07 January 1777, at age 58. John Logan, Sr. passed away on 2 December 1777, at age 77, in Washington, Connecticut, during a year marked by a smallpox epidemic. His grandson, Matthew, also died that year at age 2. While it’s uncertain if smallpox caused their deaths, it remains a likely possibility.

The Logan Lineage

The Gunn Historical Museum in the Washington Green Historic District holds numerous Logan artifacts, photographs, and stories. My connection to John Logan was confirmed through DNA testing, initially via a Yahoo group and later through collaboration with a distant cousin—the President of the Clan Logan Society International. Together, we aim to uncover the link between John Logan and his Scottish origins.

Logan name variations include Loban, Lobban, Loben, Logan, Logane, Logen, Loggan, Loggane, Loggans, and Login.

Discover more about the Lowland Logans by clicking below:


Learn about the Connecticut Logans: https://amzn.to/4cyG14M

  1. The Logans of Scotland by James C. Logan. ↩︎
  2. The Logans of Scotland by James C. Logan. ↩︎
  3. A National Register of the Society, Sons of the American Revolution, Volume 1 ↩︎
  4. A National Register of the Society, Sons of the American Revolution, Volume 1 ↩︎
  5. The Sunny Ridge Historic District archives. ↩︎
  6. Jacob Larwood and John Camden Hotten’s History of Sign Boards, p. 118. ↩︎

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Step-by-Step: Filtering Family Tree Records on Ancestry

Ever wish you could filter your Ancestry hints by a specific record group, like WWII draft cards or pension files? Here’s the trick you’ve been waiting for, thanks to the genius tip from Christa Cowan from Ancestry.com, who shared it with Aimee Cross! Now I’m sharing it with you!

𝐇𝐞𝐫𝐞’𝐬 𝐡𝐨𝐰 𝐭𝐨 𝐝𝐨 𝐢𝐭: Go to your Ancestry account and view all your hints. Sort your hints by categories like records, photos, or stories. Want to focus on a specific record group? Use the URL hack!

𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐒𝐞𝐜𝐫𝐞𝐭 𝐒𝐚𝐮𝐜𝐞:

~Grab the collection number for your desired record group.

~Replace the tree number in the URL with your tree number.

~Voilà! Filtered hints for just that record group.

Example: Searching for War of 1812 pension files?

Find the collection number in the Ancestry catalog, pop it into the URL, and get straight to those records. (eg. https://www.ancestry.com/hints/tree/𝟏𝟔𝟖𝟎𝟗𝟏𝟐𝟎𝟕/hints?hf=record&hs=last&hdbid=𝟏𝟎𝟎𝟐

(168091207 is the tree number. 1002 is the War of 1812 pension files record number. Change 168091207 to your tree number. Change 1002 to 1133 and Voilà!)

This is a game-changer for focused research. Save time, target your search, and discover those hidden items in your family tree!

Watch Aimee Cross’ video on her YouTube channel for a step-by-step visual.

I hope you found this helpful!

Make sure you subscribe to my page for more family history tips, tricks, and hacks!

The Legacy of Lewis Hollister: A Musician’s Role in the Civil War

Lewis Hollister, born on September 6, 1840, in Washington, Connecticut, was the son of Sherman Preston Hollister and Martha “Patty” Nettleton. Raised on a family farm, Lewis developed a profound love for music, mastering instruments ranging from the Jew’s harp to more complex stringed instruments. This musical talent was a cherished gift from his mother.

On August 30, 1862, at the age of 21, Lewis enlisted as a musician in Company D of the 28th Infantry Regiment Connecticut Volunteers, a nine-month volunteer unit. His leadership and musical skills earned him the position of band leader for his regiment.

The 28th Connecticut Infantry played a significant role in the Siege of Port Hudson, Louisiana, a critical campaign during the Civil War. Port Hudson was the last Confederate stronghold on the Mississippi River. The Union aimed to gain control of the river, effectively splitting the Confederacy and securing a vital transportation route. The siege, lasting from May 22 to July 9, 1863, was marked by intense combat and challenging conditions.

Tragically, during the siege, Lewis suffered a severe injury when a gunshot resulted in the loss of his finger. This injury led to subsequent illness, and he passed away on July 13, 1863. His dedication and sacrifice are remembered as part of the collective efforts that led to the Union’s strategic victory at Port Hudson.

Lewis’s story is a poignant reminder of the personal sacrifices made during the Civil War. His musical talents and leadership left an indelible mark on those who knew him, and his service contributed to a pivotal moment in American history.

Lewis’s sister married Seth Logan, a second cousin five x removed.

References

¹ “Lewis Hollister,” Washington Civil War Soldiers, washingtoncivilwarsoldiers.weebly.com.
² “Siege of Port Hudson,” American Battlefield Trust, battlefields.org.

Discovering George’s Hidden Family Story Through DNA Testing

My genealogical journey took an unexpected turn when I stumbled upon a DNA match in Ancestry’s ThruLines®. This match led me down a path that initially seemed illogical. The son of my 2nd great-grandmother’s sister, whom I had already traced, appeared to have another son with a completely unfamiliar surname. The connection was listed as “half 2nd cousin, 2x removed,” which further puzzled me.

Initially, I suspected an error in the DNA match’s family tree. However, upon further investigation, I discovered the tree was accurate. The son, let’s call him George, had adopted his mother’s maiden name. But why?

The reason for this unusual naming choice became clear when I learned more about George’s unconventional upbringing. His parents, let’s call them Sal and Sandra, had him out of wedlock. Sandra, unable to care for him alone, entrusted him to her parents for the first year.

Tragedy struck when Sandra’s mother passed away, leaving her father to raise George with the help of his siblings. However, the situation further deteriorated when Sandra’s husband refused to accept George.

At the age of four, George was placed in an infant asylum, a Catholic institution where he was baptized and circumcised. The records revealed that his biological father, Sal, had initially provided financial support but ultimately failed to maintain it. As a result, George was transferred to another orphanage for older children at the age of six.

Life at the orphanage was undoubtedly challenging. George received a basic education, but his academic performance was described as “low to average.” At sixteen, he was placed with a farming family, where he lived and worked until he married at twenty-five.

George rarely spoke about his time in the orphanages, suggesting deeply painful experiences. His mother, who had another daughter with her husband, completely disowned him. The cruelty extended even to the mother’s funeral, where his own half-sister forbade him from attending.

Furthermore, George’s family was deliberately misled about his biological father’s ethnicity. They were told he was of a different nationality, a blatant lie to conceal his true origins.

The discovery of this hidden past through DNA testing has been a profound revelation for George’s descendants. They now have a vast extended family they never knew existed, and I am honored to be able to assist them in connecting with this newfound heritage.

This experience underscores the power of DNA testing in uncovering unexpected family histories and the importance of preserving family stories, even the most difficult ones.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

A Scandalous Love Story: The Common-Law Marriage of John Weskett and Barbara Midgett in 1800s North Carolina

In the early 1800s on Roanoke Island, North Carolina, a romance blossomed that would challenge the social and legal norms of the time. This is the story of my 4th great-grandparents, John Weskett Jr. and Barbara “Barby” Midgett, whose relationship began as a scandal but endured to become a legitimate marriage spanning decades.

The Early Years

Barbara Midgett was born in 1787 and came from a prominent Roanoke Island family. In 1802, at just 15 years old, she married Ambrose N. Dough, an 18-year-old mariner1. The marriage seemed promising at first, with Barbara bringing 76 acres of inherited land to the union2. However, their relationship would soon take an unexpected turn.

A Marriage Falls Apart

While Ambrose was away at sea, Barbara began a relationship with John Weskett Jr., who was born between 1774 and 1780. By 1807, Barbara and John were living together openly, having already welcomed two children. When Ambrose returned from his voyage to discover this new arrangement, he found himself in an impossible situation.

The Failed Divorce Petition

In 1809, Ambrose petitioned the North Carolina legislature for divorce. In his emotional appeal, he described how he had improved Barbara’s land during their marriage but had “declined any further use of the same” after discovering her relationship with Weskett. Despite support from several prominent citizens, including members of the legislature, his petition was denied.

Property and Financial Matters

In an interesting twist, despite his complaints to the legislature, Ambrose had already sold Barbara’s 76 acres to John Weskett in 1804 for 400 silver dollars. This transaction would later become part of a complex web of property arrangements between the three parties.

A Family Grows

Unable to marry legally until after Ambrose’s death, John and Barbara continued their life together, eventually having seven children: Thomas, Samuel, Patrick, Sally, Polly, Harriett, and John (my 3rd great-grandfather). Their relationship, though technically illegal, was accepted enough in the community that they were able to conduct business and own property.

Legal Marriage at Last

On December 22, 1824, John and Barbara were finally able to formalize their relationship. They signed a detailed marriage contract that carefully protected Barbara’s property rights and provided for their children’s inheritance. This contract offers a fascinating glimpse into both the legal complexities of the time and the couple’s commitment to securing their family’s future.

Later Years

By 1830, Barbara had established herself as head of her own household, according to census records. The family owned three slaves initially, though by 1840 this number had decreased to one. The census also notes “1 insane white” in the household, possibly referring to John’s brother James.

Wescott Home.jpg

Home of three generations of Wescott's built around 1810. 
Moved from Manteo Airport in 1942 by D. Victor Meekins

Historical Significance

This family story has attracted scholarly attention, being featured in several academic works examining legal culture and gender relations in the post-Revolutionary South. It provides valuable insights into marriage, property rights, and social norms in early American society.

Endnotes

Barbara Midgett, The People and Their Peace: Currituck County, North Carolina, 1728–2000 (Currituck, North Carolina: Currituck County Historical Society, 2005), 170; digital images, Google Books (https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_People_and_Their_Peace/0cU3CwAAQBAJ: accessed 22 March 2026), entry referencing Barbara Midgett.

“Dare, North Carolina, United States records,” images, FamilySearch ({{FamilySearch Image | 3QSQ-G982-YCQW}} : Mar 23,
2026), image 414 of 668; Dare County (North Carolina). Register of Deeds.
Image Group Number: 007538808

Barbara Midgett, The People and Their Peace: Currituck County, North Carolina, 1728–2000 (Currituck, North Carolina: Currituck County Historical Society, 2005), 170; digital images, Google Books (https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_People_and_Their_Peace/0cU3CwAAQBAJ: accessed 22 March 2026), discussion of Ambrose’s legislative complaint and prior sale of Barbara Midgett’s 76 acres to John Weskett in 1804 for 400 silver dollars.

Barbara Midgett, The People and Their Peace: Currituck County, North Carolina, 1728–2000 (2005), 170–171; digital images, Google Books (https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_People_and_Their_Peace/0cU3CwAAQBAJ
: accessed 22 March 2026).

Barbara Midgett, The People and Their Peace: Currituck County, North Carolina, 1728–2000 (Currituck, North Carolina: Currituck County Historical Society, 2005), 170–171; digital images, Google Books (https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_People_and_Their_Peace/0cU3CwAAQBAJ: accessed 22 March 2026), describing the relationship of John Wescott and Barbara Midgett and naming their children Thomas, Samuel, Patrick, Sally, Polly, Harriett, and John.

“Currituck, North Carolina, United States records,” images, FamilySearch ({{FamilySearch Image | 3QS7-898B-WTH}} : Mar 23, 2026),
image 343 of 582; North Carolina. County Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions (Currituck County). Image Group Number: 007513637

1830 U.S. census, Currituck County, North Carolina, population schedule, John Wescott household; digital images, Ancestry ({{Ancestry Record|8058|185142}}: accessed 22 March 2026); citing National Archives microfilm publication M19.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.